Well 3 points is 3 points toward the approx 45 point safety target so the result was a relief in that respect. However it was far from a barnstorming opening to the season which should have seen an average QPR side easily swept away. The shape and method of the Rovers did rather perturb and certainly disappoint me.
1. Long ball after long ball from defence up to four tightly marked forwards virtually within touching distance of each other is NOT the way forward in this league. That is the tactic of park football played on a quagmire pitch rendering short crisp interchanges nigh on impossible. Were it not for Travis's thunderbolt I feel this match would have ended in a 0-0 stalemate because of the dearth of chances created. Ok so most would know that we were always going to miss Joe Rothwell's ability to carry the ball forward at speed, putting opponents on to the back foot and introduce a level of panic to defences, or indeed Khadra and Dolan's trickery and unpredictability. Rothwell's skill sadly was most missing today. Also largely missing was much of the crisp passing interchanges of last season until midway through the second half.
2. Width. Where was it? With no one creating space for the other forwards by hugging the touchline our attacking play came to a halt in a bottleneck of players as outlined above. Worse still with all that space down the flanks both full backs seemed strangely reluctant to cross the half way line with any sort of attacking intent.
If we are to finish above half way this season all concerned will need to take a long hard look at this match on all the plethora of screens down at Brockhall this next week.
Kaminsky... 6 A decent performance let down by some poor distribution and a couple of errors of judgement and application that on another ....day might prove very costly. Why he didn't shout KEEPERS BALL to Scott Wharton in one incident when both went for the same ball I have no idea. It's a goalkeeping basic!
Brittain .. 6 A decent enough showing today which I'm sure will improve once he is more familiar with his teammates. Needs to show more attacking intent.
Ayala... 8 Strong performance in which he and Scotty W virtually snuffed out any threat from QPR's front man Lyndon Dykes and kept QPR's attacking stats to 0 shots on target and 0 corners
Wharton.. 7 See above.
Pickering... 6 Tested early on and was struggling somewhat as most of QPR's attacking was down their right wing. Reluctant to venture fwd on a number of occasions. We all know that he does possess attacking instincts so was this down to a one off or instructions to stay back from the new Management team?
Travis... 8 Absolute blinder of a goal from the Rovers new Captain. Thank goodness he did find that shot or two home points would have been frittered. Combative in midfield as ever and left a few 'calling cards' as he softened up opposing midfielders. He, Buckley and the defence did well to keep QPR's precocious creative danger man Ilias Chair quiet.
Buckley... 7 Decent match without the normal creative influence that we know he is capable of. Probably crowded out by the narrowness of Hedges, Vale, BBD and Gallagher leaving him no space to work with or carry the ball into. Spent a lot of time on defensive duties and was booked in the first half for a clash as a result of temper after being flattened by Dykes and Referee Bramall giving no foul. It left Buckley walking on egg shells for the rest of the match. Dykes btw joining him in the book which was odd as he was booked for a foul which he had not awarded at the time. Work that one out if you can. Bramall's report should make comical reading.
Gallagher.... 6 Put himself about and gave plenty of effort but again hampered by the close proximity of his teammates.
Hedges.. 6 See above re: Gally. Must say I was rather surprised to see him play the full 93 minutes.
Vale.... 6 Started well and looked lively but suffered as the two above from lack of space, faded in the second half and was replaced by Dolan on 64mins.
BBD... 6 Did good and bad in fairly equal measure. If there were scouts watching him today I don't think he showed enough for any to recommend a 20m investment to their bosses. Scored a disallowed goal that should have sealed a 2-0 win in the dying minutes but had thoughtlessly charged forward into a (way) offside position to meet Dolan's cross. Why tf a professional player should have done that in that position when he could see right along the line is virtually unforgiveable!
Sub
Dolan (64 mins for Vale) 7. Came on and immediately unsettled the QPR defence with his trickery. Faded a little as the forwards were left to work off breaks rather than periods of attacking pressure. Was unlucky to miss out on an assist through BBD's amateurish error.
Manager Tomasson ... 5 Not the best performance for the opening game. Early days but he needs to send out a better balanced team at Swansea. Just one man in midfield with any sort of a tackle in him and any number of forwards virtually holding hands and throttling attacking intent will not bring home the bacon often enough!
Referee Thomas Bramall 7. We've only had this chap once and that was our loss at Hull City away last season. He's never been to Ewood and after a shaky start when he booked Buckley and Dykes he settled into the match. He could have sent off Buckley for a second offence but chose to deliver what must have been a final warning rather than a second yellow and the match was saved as a spectacle for the 14315 in Ewood Park. Seemed to get most things right for the rest of the match.
(So odd that so many elect to pay on the day when a ST would offer so much better value.)