• NEXT GAME:Leicester City FC
    Saturday 4th May 2024
    Kick off 12.30 pm
    Kingpower Stadium
    Championship

July 3, 1973. The day the music died?

Wilpshire Blue

Senior Member
Without doubt Dylan’s lyrics in ‘ Hard Rains A Gonna Fall ‘ were deep , meaningful, and thought provoking . Just like the best writers / poets he communicated with creativity , imagination and feeling . I get that .

However when you decide to transfer those words into a song , then it’s the melody that takes over . Songs are created for communicating melody . Melody turns the words into something that’s pleasant to the ears . In a poem for example , it’s the words that are the main focus , in a song it’s the melody .

Dylan’s voice isn’t melodic , it grates on the ears and is particularly unpleasant . First time I’ve heard Patti Smith , but she’s not much of an improvement on Dylan 😉 Did she forget the words or is she just a good actress ? Just googled her and she wrote/ sang a song “ Smells Like Teen Spirit “ Are you a fan SLKS ?

Edit : apologies SLKS , just read that it’s by a group called Nirvana !
Come on OOT, I know you're mainly a Motown man but surely you knew "Smells Like Teen Spirit" was the song that thrust Nirvana into the big time?
 

Drog

Administrator
Staff member
Kurt Cobain actually wrote it according to google.
 

OnlyOneTugay

Prediction Champion 2019 & 2020
Bob Dylan - no not at all, OOT. but I get why others are. Agree, some writers should leave the delivery to better performers. Billy Bragg's probably another one.
Sorry SLKS mislead you , I was referring to the “ Smells Like Teen Spirit “ I thought you might be a fan of the song as your moniker is fairly similar .
 

OnlyOneTugay

Prediction Champion 2019 & 2020
Come on OOT, I know you're mainly a Motown man but surely you knew "Smells Like Teen Spirit" was the song that thrust Nirvana into the big time?
Ha ha ha ! I’m sure I’ll get hung , drawn and quartered by some of the music aficionados on here , but Nirvana must have completely passed me by . Probably busy bringing up the children when they were ‘ thrust ‘ into the big time !
 

Drog

Administrator
Staff member
Ditto OOT. There are certain bands that are/have been mega that I could hardly name a track they played. Pink Floyd along with most of the 70's rock bands being one I'm afraid to say. People play 'familiar' rock tracks (some get out the old air guitar for supposed effect) and I've absolutely no idea who they are by.
 
Last edited:

CLW-BRFC

Senior Member
If any of you want to listen to a masterpiece then listen to Nirvana mtv unplugged in New York. Jesus dont want me for a sunbeam makes me emotional. In a good way.
 
I know Van Morrison is campaigning to restore live music concerts with full capacity audiences, but I've a feeling this pandemic might have ended any last chance we had to see of the likes of the The Who (England's best ever rock band?), Fleetwood Mac and the ultimate rock come back, one last Led Zep tour. So many things have changed in 2020, but heck, watching Fleetwood Mac in their prime; somehow, our Stevie seems to have made the time stand still...

1599941006302.png
 
Last edited:

Drog

Administrator
Staff member
So much for the rumour at the time that McArtney was dead based on him being out of step with the others eh? Turned out that he wasn't dead but he was definitely out of step.
 

OnlyOneTugay

Prediction Champion 2019 & 2020
BF 75 today :eek: and still going strong judging by his recent appearance in the brilliant Babylon Berlin:

Wow :eek: it only seems like yesterday when I bought my first single , Virginia Plain .

If my maths are correct , Brian Ferry was just 26 in this video , TOTP 24th August 1972 .


The speed of things 😟
 
Last edited:

OnlyOneTugay

Prediction Champion 2019 & 2020
As England are making hard work of beating Italy , you’ve inspired me to reconsider SLKS . If they don’t do the business, the Bene will still flow tonight in celebration of that lot down the M65 being firmly rooted at the bottom .

Music ? My vinyl copy of Marvin’s classic “ What’s Going On “ An appropriate anthem after today’s result

Up the Rovers .

Edit : England now 24-5 up and needing just one more try for the bonus point .
 
As England are making hard work of beating Italy , you’ve inspired me to reconsider SLKS . If they don’t do the business, the Bene will still flow tonight in celebration of that lot down the M65 being firmly rooted at the bottom .

Music ? My vinyl copy of Marvin’s classic “ What’s Going On “ An appropriate anthem after today’s result

Up the Rovers .

Edit : England now 24-5 up and needing just one more try for the bonus point .
Never underestimate the versatility of the bene OOT!
 
Top